Anxious as we are to find out who the deeply disturbed killer is on Harper’s Island? Join the staff of KCF and fans of Katie by piecing the clues together so we can figure out who it is!

What do you have to do? It’s simple! Just fill out the form below with clues or thoughts you have about who could be the person in control of this murderous rampage. Put your name, email, and then everything you have to say. After you send it in, we will post it on this page and fans can respond to each other and read together!

Name:
Email Address:
The killer is...
Why?

After Episode 7: “Thrack, Splat, Sizzle”

• 1. Britt
  Who is the killer?: The sheriff. Well, after last weeks episode, I just think he’s kinda shady! And he’s probably the last person anyone would think of! So, I really think he’s the killer!

After Episode 6: “Sploosh”

• 1. Kim
  Who is the killer?: I think Abby is just messed up about her mom I would say it has to be her or Wakefield isn’t really dead. But after yesterday’s episode who is the guy with the scarred face????
• 2. Trish
  Who is the killer?: Love Katie, but the character is a bit overdone. She seems like she pulls “victim” all over the place. Maybe shes really not so much of a victim after all. If its not Katie, I think either the Sheriff, the little girl, and after reading Brittney’s guess, Cal sounds pretty suspicious. Maybe Cal was Wakefields son, maybe hes faking a British accent. And who is the guy with the scarred face and attack dog?!

After Episode 5: “Thawk”

• 1. Hannah
  Who is the killer?: Henry
• 2. Kirstie
  Who is the killer?: I think it’s either Trish or Henry! More so Henry, because I don’t think Trish would kill her own father. I believe it’s either one of them because why did they want the wedding on that island? They could have had it anywhere else in the world but they chose there. And although Trish has had attacks on herself, I think it’s only because she’s trying to “show” it’s not her.
• 3. Becca
  Who is the killer?: The Sheriff.
• 4. Analeigh
  Who is the killer?: I think it’s Abby because she might be really screwed up from the attack on her mom and other people’s mom before. I think she’s having split personalities, one where she takes on Wakefield in her mind and the other where she’s herself. She hasn’t been attacked yet and she seems to very well up to date on what’s going on on the Island, even though no one else is aware of the murders.
• 5. Brina
  Who is the killer?: I don’t think that Wakefeild is really dead. I think that the sheriff thinks that he killed him but I don’t think that he did.
• 6. Sophia
  Who is the killer?: The Sherriff because he was married to Abby’s mom so, for some reason, he might have killed her and he couldn’t kill her daughter. The murderers stopped when she ran away to LA and now she’s back, the killer is back too and keeps surrounding Abby like before.
• 7. Matty
  Who is the killer?: She broke the china and is a creepy girl.
• 8. Brittney
  Who is the killer?: Cal. He’s just got that weird vibe about him, and his almost drowning Chloe in the lake shows he has a violent side. Not to mention Chloe has an extreme love and fascination of serial killers and murderers… He was hanging upside down and lived, even though he was a sitting duck for the killer. But he has no personal relationships with anyone, therefore he has no problem killing people off like flies.
• 9.  Allison
  Who is the killer?: He’s the last person anyone would suspect, and in ‘gurgle’ he had these cuts that came outta nowhere.